The verdict in the Zimmerman case has been percolating in my head since last night. I think the jury reached a legally correct verdict, but it would be wrong to say I feel happy about it. My head understands the legal angle, however I have to admit that my heart is still troubled. And that's even though I think Trayvon Martin bears as much if not more responsibility as Zimmerman for the events that led up to the shooting. Here are a few points as I try to figure a few things out.
-Protests and rallies last night and today were nearly all peaceful. There was a minor disturbance in LA last night that had officers firing beanbags to disperse a crowd and a mini-riot in Oakland, but it seems like pretty much every night is a mini-riot in Oakland. As Glenn Reynolds noted this morning, "...as usual, people are behaving better in real life than they do on the Internet." Hopefully the same applies to the Internet death threats to Zimmerman, his family, his lawyers, and the jurors. As of today, those jurors are still choosing to stay anonymous. Probably because of some overblown and racist fear.
-We would need a supernatural license for hyperbole to match this enormous steaming pile from Paul Campos, which among other things includes this lie:
Because this is America, pointing out that a black boy can be shot with impunity by a more or less white man because many white Americans are terrified by black boys and men is called “playing the race card.”
The same goes for this from Matthew Yglesias:
Pro tip: If you want to kill someone in America and avoid jail time, make sure to kill a young black man.
Right. I could walk out my front door tomorrow and blow away the black teenage boy who lives across the street from me "with impunity," with no jail time.
In fairness to Yglesias, who I sometimes suspect is borderline retarded, he may actually believe that might be true. On the other hand Campos, a law professor at the University of Colorado at Boulder, has to know he is lying. I'll probably come back to Campos later, but talk about a walking disgrace to higher education.
-It's depressing how so many people continue to cling to falsehoods about the case. I mean they are willfully denying facts that do not match the narrative they want to believe. These people are challenging my life-long belief that most people are basically good and maybe only 20% are actually rotten to the core. This case has me thinking that maybe the numbers are the opposite.
Unfortunately, I think Jonathan Turley gets it right here:
With the verdict, the Zimmerman case entered the realm of legal mythology -- a tale told by different groups in radically different ways for different meanings. Fax machines were activated with solicitations and sound bites long ago programmed for this moment. The legal standards long ago seemed to be lost to the social symbolism of the case.
Criminal cases make for perfect and often dangerous vehicles for social expression. They allow longstanding social and racial issues to be personified in villains and victims. We simplify facts and characters -- discarding those facts that do not fit our narrative. We pile meanings on the outcome that soon make the actual murder secondary to the message. Zimmerman and Martin became proxies in our national debate over race. There was little patience or need for the niceties of rules of proof and adjudication.
If you don't see the tragedy in Trayvon Martin's death that night, you are an asshole. The ugly flip side of that coin is the brutal, sickeningly callous demonization of George Zimmerman that is unsupported by the facts. Two sides of the same coin.
-I think the harsh criticism of the prosecution's conduct all along is well-founded. I buy this case that the affidavit they filed to charge second degree murder left out key pieces of exculpatory evidence. I think the charge of second degree murder was a disastrous overreach that was unsupported by the evidence from the beginning. I think a case focused on manslaughter with related lesser charges would have likely resulted in a least one conviction and a few years of prison for Zimmerman.
The charges and the manner in how the evidence was presented to the jury left them with no options to put responsibility on Zimmerman in a way that wasn't an injustice to him.
-I'll probably have more on this, but it's getting late at this point.
Recent Comments