Enviro Mental: We have to kill the birds to save them...
A controversial wind farm proposed near Red Wing plans to ask for federal permission to legally kill eagles, making it one of the first in the nation to participate in a new federal strategy aimed at managing the often-lethal conflict between birds and turbine blades.
U.S. Fish and Wildlife officials say they urged the developers of AWA Goodhue Wind to seek the new permit because the deaths of an unknown number of eagles and endangered golden eagles will be inevitable once the 50-turbine project is up and running.
I don't like wind farms. I don't like them because they are giant, whirring, bird killing monuments to stupid. Decades from now, children will gaze upon them in wonder and ask their parents why people were so stupid way back then.
It's not the technology itself that is stupid. Windmills can be very useful in doing all sorts of things, including generating electricity in some circumstances. My dad grew up on a farm that used windmill power to pump well water to the house and livestock barns. That application made perfect sense. And if I were to build a new cabin these days I would consider solar and wind to generate electricity. The self-sufficiency might outweigh the extra cost. No, the problem isn't the technology itself, which isn't stupid at all, it's the attempt to scale it beyond its capabilities to the electric utility level.
About 125 years ago, several different people figured out how to attach a generator to a windmill and produce electricity. That free source of energy appealed to the greedy power company executives and they erected tens of thousands of windmills all across the country.
Oh, wait. That didn't happen. Well, that's because the greed of the power company executives was outweighed by their insatiable desire to burn fossil fuels. "God I love the smell of burning coal in the morning!", they cried as one.
Oh, wait. That didn't happen either. What did happen was the greedy power company executives felt all that free wind energy just blowing around and they tasked their best engineers to figure out how to capture it. And figure it out they did. There was one little problem though: By the time they built the damned things the electricity produced was so expensive that their customers couldn't afford it and it was unreliable as hell to boot.
In other words, to go down that path would have been stupid, so they didn't. The End.
Oh, wait. Stupid obviously has a nasty way of living to stupid another day. All over us. Sometimes on a grander scale than ever before.
Enter our federal and state governments, of course.
The states pass the mandates and the feds hand out the subsidies by the billions each year. That's the only reason why these wind farms are being built. The only reason. They make no economic sense, and by the time you add the ecological costs of the materials and the mostly natural gas power plants needed to stabilize the grid because of these beasts, I don't think they are actually "green" at all.
Well, they're certainly "green" for the appropriately named "Big Wind" industry, but not for anybody else.
Ah, the heck with it. Let's go kill some eagles for Gaia!
Recent Comments